Thursday, October 24, 2013

The Challenges of Determining What is "Excessive"

The principle of proportionality is a fundamental component of IHL, based on the notion that parties to an armed conflict do not have unlimited means in which to exact damage on an enemy. Nonetheless, civilian casualties during conflict are more than an on the ground reality, they are a consequence of a complex and ambiguous legal calculus recognized during hostilities. So how does IHL control excessive casualties? Article 51 (5)(b) of Additional Protocol I places this responsibility on the attacker, justifying resulting incidental civilian casualties and damage only if the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated is greater. Operationally this proportionality calculus has proven problematic. Especially difficult and commonly disputed is whether proportionality must take into account the entire conflict timeframe. This critical uncertainty can pose an incredible strain on governments, militaries and IHL. Furthermore, this ambiguity can result in additional casualties.

The challenges surrounding excessive casualties were discussed at NBOL’s 2013 workshop - The Operationalization of the Law: Enhancing the Symmetry between IHL and Military Operational Art - hosted at the ICT’s 13th World Summit on Counter-Terrorism.

Highlighted are two quotes, one from Col. (Ret) Richard M. Whitaker, Judge Advocate, U.S. Army, and Mr. Anton Camen of the ICRC delegation in Israel. 

As always we encourage you to share your opinions in the comment section below.
Click image for larger view


  1. Really good quotes that are highlighted in this post.

    Read latest news on Russia World Cup 2018

  2. You have covered all points in this Article.This article is simple awesome which provides extra knowledge also.Thanks for sharing such a great post with us.


  3. Interesting information and satisfy certainly can create a page popular, successful greetings
    perfileman Alat bantu wanita.
    perfileman Alat bantu pria.
    jual toys murah
    dildo murah

  4. Great post. Preserve posting such form of information to your paganism genuinely inspired by means of your weblog.

    Goa Fashion escorts service.

  5. Αυτό είναι πραγματικά το καλύτερο blog για όποιον θέλει να αποκαλύψει έξω για αυτό το θέμα. Και θέλω να ζητήσω από οποιονδήποτε να χρησιμοποιήσει αυτή την mac hard disk recovery. Δυστυχώς έχασα τα αρχεία μου. Δεν ξέρω πώς να το κάνω. Ελπίζω ότι κάποιος μπορεί να με βοηθήσει. HTML To XML Parser, cara bermain bitcoin, cara menghilangkan jerawat, klasifikasi tanaman, manfaat jamblang, lirik lagu terbaru, tanaman obat keluarga, beton instan terbaik, cara menghilangkan bau ketiak

  6. I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.

  7. One major starting point for CSPs and ISP’s NFV solutions is the deployment of virtual CPE (consumer premise equipment), specifically the business oriented variation vE-CPE – Virtual enterprise CPE. The immediate benefits in reduced CapEx and flexibility make growing enterprise networks one of the first to receive NFV solutions in the form of vCPE from service providers.

    But there are still hurdles to overcome, and 3 different Virtual CPE implementations have been developed as a solution to some of these problems. In this article I will detail the 3 different kinds of implementations as well as existing problems that prevent service providers from implementing “full” vCPE, cloud hosted solutions.
    Virtual CPE, the first step in service providers’ NFV promise – vendor agnostic networks…