Friday, January 17, 2014

PART II – Dershowitz Analyzed: An Insufficiently Broad Condemnation of a Complicated and Malleable Regime


This post is the second of a three part series regarding Alan Dershowitz’s recent criticism of international law (to see his full remarks, please use the link in the last blog post). During this entry I intend to concentrate on some of Dershowitz’s observations on international law, both stated and implied, with a particular focus on their relevance to IHL. This response will address certain legal and philosophical issues expansive enough for many scholars to devote lifetimes too. I only attempt to scratch the surface on what I hope will continue to be a proactive, healthy and lengthy debate on these subjects. 

Dershowitz aptly notes that rationality must be understood as a product of perspective within a given context. However, this does not mean that certain ethical concerns in the name of humanity cannot be codified, ratified and generally implemented. The vast majority of the world’s nations have come together to create and advance numerous treaties and prohibitions delineating the use of force in conflict. The United Nations and Geneva Conventions are the best representations of this universal attempt to protect and advance humanitarian goals. Specifically, nearly every nation has agreed to adhere to the foundational principles of IHL: distinction, necessity, proportionality, and humanity. As Dershowitz knows well as a distinguished defense attorney, just because a small, even dangerous minority may not follow the law, it does not mean that the law itself has failed.

Nevertheless ethical norms that help define humanitarian aims are constantly changing. In this regard international law, unlike other legal constructs that may improperly constrain progressive applications due to their structural rigidity, is designed to recognize and usurp customary modifications. Along with ethical changes, technological advancement has completely altered the way war is both conceived and decided. Consequently who is most affected by war has changed dramatically. Today, the vast majority of casualties during armed conflict are civilian. It is not only logical; it is necessary for IHL to adjust to this reality in order to maintain relevance.

Dershowitz however, attacks this flexibility, arguing that international law has turned into a left-wing academic exercise in fantasy. This is, of course, patently false. Dershowitz is insinuating that a dichotomy exists between damage to the enemy and protection of civilians. Yet IHL as well as most of its scholars and practitioners do not see these concerns as contradictory or mutually exclusive. Additionally, IHL is embraced and advanced by almost every organized military in the world – codified in military handbooks, disseminated by military officials, regulated in the field by military advisors and officers, as well as explored in military institutions of higher learning. “Rational” operational concerns are both loudly and commonly voiced within forums aimed at advancing IHL – including our own IHLToday.com. The structure of IHL not only encourages military and state participation, it requires it.  

Dershowitz’s most potent and reasonable critique is that international law does not necessarily produce the most favorable outcome from a state’s individual perspective, thus diminishing both its practicality and value to this state. But is the law of war intended to serve individual states? If not, whom? This question has been contemplated since pagan antiquity. The best answer may be a non-answer. International Law’s structure is designed to preserve life – civilian or combatant. Doing so requires the cooperation of states (and increasingly non-state actors), international organizations as well as individuals. International law admittedly prospers when the reciprocity of its aims are respected by all relevant belligerents. However international law’s greatest successes have arguably occurred when one party to a conflict upholds this doctrine despite flagrant violations by its enemy.   

International law (IHL included) does not always provide a clear, practical or even beneficial (by its own stated goals) comprehension of the law. It is absolutely critical that we choose to address these situations as soon as possible by shaping IHL’s already pliable structure to ensure it suits both contemporary norms and conflict reality. Anecdotally, I fully admit that IHL is far from perfect. I personally acknowledge certain rare actualities where violating the law of armed conflict as it is currently appreciated is necessary to uphold its core principles (famously elaborated by Gabriella Blum). I do not believe that these circumstances warrant IHL’s broad dismissal or prejudicial condemnation. I believe they warrant dialogue. This is the very purpose of IHLToday.com. Please continue to follow, share and participate. 
Click image for larger view

117 comments:

  1. Thanks for the information, may I quote some parts of this article, because it is very interesting and useful. regard Ilmu Pelet

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ilmu Pelet. Thank you for your kind comment. You may quote anything from our blog, we encourage it. It would be great for you to provide a link to your work which quotes us. We would love to see your thoughts and explorations.

      Delete
  2. Good post. I just wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
    Bisnis online 2014

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for sharing this information! I will get back for more later. Here is the site:
    http://watchmoviesonline365.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for sharing in this article
    I can learn a lot and could also be a reference
    I am happy to find your website and can join to comment
    I think is very valuable to be able to read your writing, and on this occasion will I use for my reference source
    Thank you so much for sharing, I hope you continue to write spirit next topic
    vimax extender harga hp terbaru

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am impressed by the quality of information on this website. There are a lot of good resources here. I am sure I will visit this place again soon....

    Pesawat Tempur Siluman Tercanggih

    ReplyDelete
  6. I am happy to visit this blog, many articles that provide new knowledge and are very useful for me, I get a lot of new knowledge. Thank you.
    catering surabaya
    -best vacuum cleaner for pet hair
    - proactol reviews

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice write-up! If you want to promote your blog site for free, leave a comment at http://www.coreforceworldwide.com/why-we-write-for-you/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Politics, Artist, JKT48
    technology and Software
    Sport and Travel
    Online Business
    Health


    http://rezadelorton.blogspot.com
    http://downloadsoftwarerdo.blogspot.com
    http://bisnisonlinenomodal.blogspot.com
    http://carasehatslalu.blogspot.com
    http://toolseosoft.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. yang dihasilkan oleh lebah madu dari nektar bunga yang sedang mekar atau dari sekresi bagian tanaman selain bunga atau sekresi bagian tanaman selain bunga yang diisap oleh serangga, jual hdi

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I know where I'm going and l know the truth, and I don't have to be what you want me to be. I'm free to be what I want.Thankyou i really love it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Exceilent blog you have here but I was curious abou t if you knew of any communi ty forums tha t cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other experienced individuaIs that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it.....

    ReplyDelete
  13. Exceilent blog you have here but I was curious abou t if you knew of any communi ty forums tha t cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other experienced individuaIs that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it.....

    ReplyDelete
  14. You have raised an important issue..Thanks for sharing..I would like to read more current affairs from this blog..keep posting..

    NIAGAPOKER.COM AGEN JUDI POKER ONLINE DAN BANDAR DOMINO TERPERCAYA

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very good idea you've shared here, from here I can be a very valuable
    new experience. all things that are here will I make the source of
    reference, thank you friends.
    http://www.klgpembesar.com/
    http://jualobatpembesar.org/
    http://distributor-vimax.com/
    http://ruangdewasa.com/
    http://semenaxindonesia.biz/
    http://obatpembesarpenis.distributor-vimax.com/
    http://www.vimaxpembesar.us/
    http://alatbantusemarang.com/
    http://vimax.seksualitas.info/
    http://apotikobatvimax.com/
    http://obatvimaxcanada.com/
    http://tipsyudi.blogspot.co.id/
    http://sekilasternak.blogspot.co.id/
    http://thiapesek.blogspot.co.id/
    http://bugile.net/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Lombok Rinjani Trekking information Rinjani Trekking www.halomitrekker.com
    Rinjani Trekking Centre Rinjani Trek Centre www.rinjanitrekkingcentre.com
    Rinjani Trekking tour packages Rinjani Trekking Packages www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani National park Rinjani Trekking Information www.halomitrekker.com
    Rinjani Summit Summitting Rinjani www.halomitrekker.com
    Speed boat to gili islands Gili Lombok Speed Boat www.halomitrekker.com
    Gili islands information Gilis Islands www.halomitrekker.com
    Go to gili islands Getting to the Gilis www.halomitrekker.com
    Rinjani personal daypack Rinjani requerements www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Information Best part Rinjani Mountain www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Information, Green Rinjani trekking Green For Mount Rinjani www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Information Rinjani daily weather forecast www.halomitrekker.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. Mount Rinjani Information History of mount Rinjani www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani InformationMain object of Rinjani www.halomitrekker.com
    Rinjani Trekking Information Rinjani trekking Routes www.halomitrekker.com
    Rinjani Trekking Information Rinjani trekking via Senaru www.halomitrekker.com
    Rinjani Trekking InformationRinjani trekking via Sembalun www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani TrekkingRinjani Senaru Accommodation hotel www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Trekking Rinjani trekking 2 days 1 night crater senaru www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Trekking Rinjani Trekking 3 days 2 Nights lake via Senaru www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Trekking Rinjani Trekking 3 days 2 days summit via senaru www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Trekking Rinjani Trekking 4 Days 3 Nights summit via Senaru www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount rinjani Trekking Rinjani Trekking 2 Days 1 Night summit via Sembalun www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount rinjani Trekking Rinjani Trekking 3 Days 2 nights summit via Sembalun www.halomitrekker.com
    Mount Rinjani Trekking Rinjani Trekking 4 Days 3 nights summit via Sembalun www.halomitrekker.com

    ReplyDelete
  18. Jika anda ingin mencari tahu tentang cara menggugurkan kandungan , banyak sekali kita temukan di google tentang artikel cara gugurkan kandungan secara alami maupun dengan menggunakan obat . bahkan banyak toko online jual obat aborsi yang bertebaran di dunia maya .

    ReplyDelete
  19. mantappp
    http://vimaxasli-herbal.com/

    ReplyDelete
  20. memberi solusi semua problem seks pasutri yang paling bagus.
    solusi cepat dan tepat segala masalah seks anda.

    ReplyDelete
  21. memberi solusi semua problem seks pasutri yang paling bagus.
    solusi cepat dan tepat segala masalah seks anda.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Very good idea you've shared here, from here I can be a very valuable
    new experience. all things that are here will I make the source of
    reference, thank you friends

    Click Here: Obat Aborsi

    Click Here: Obat Aborsi

    Click Here: Obat Aborsi 1 Bulan

    Click Here: Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan

    Click Here: Obat Aborsi 1 Bulan

    Click Here: Obat Aborsi 2 Bulan

    Click Here: Obat Aborsi 4 Bulan

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thank you for sharing in this article
    I can learn a lot and could also be a reference
    I am happy to find your website and can join to comment
    I think is very valuable to be able to read your writing, and on this occasion will I use for my reference source
    Thank you so much for sharing, I hope you continue to write spirit next topic

    VIMAX

    OBAT PEMBESAR PENIS

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you for sharing in this article
    I can learn a lot and could also be a reference
    I am happy to find your website and can join to comment
    I think is very valuable to be able to read your writing, and on this occasion will I use for my reference source
    Thank you so much for sharing, I hope you continue to write spirit next topic

    VIMAX

    OBAT PEMBESAR PENIS

    ReplyDelete
  25. Interesting information and satisfy certainly can create a page popular, successful greetings
    perfileman Alat bantu wanita.
    perfileman Alat bantu pria.
    jual Alat bantu murah
    jual dildo murah

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hello very nice website Video Bokep!! Guy , .. Excellent .. Super ..
    I will bookmark your site and take the feeds also?
    I am glad to search out a lot of useful info here
    in the post, we’d like work out more strategies on this
    regard, thank you for sharing,. googd your blogs Streaming Video Bokep

    ReplyDelete
  27. 점을 보완하여 Cytotec 양자대결이나 라이벌 대결 등으로 사전에 10점을 심사위원 Obat Penggugur 재량으로 줄 수 있는 권한까지 부여하였다. 그러함에도 불구하고 Obat Telat Bulan 실력면에서 상대적으로 월등한 송희진의 3강에서 결승에 오르지 못하자 Obat Cytotec 심사위원들은 멘붕에 빠졌다

    ReplyDelete
  28. 점을 보완하여 Cytotec 양자대결이나 라이벌 대결 등으로 사전에 10점을 심사위원 Obat Penggugur 재량으로 줄 수 있는 권한까지 부여하였다. 그러함에도 불구하고 Obat Telat Bulan 실력면에서 상대적으로 월등한 송희진의 3강에서 결승에 오르지 못하자 Obat Cytotec 심사위원들은 멘붕에 빠졌다








































    ReplyDelete
  29. Appreciating the time and energy you put into your blog and detailed information you present.
    It’s great to come across a blog every once
    Photoshop CC Crack
    PS3 Emulator for PC

    ReplyDelete
  30. Cara cepat dan mudah memperbesar penis dengan cara aman dan sehat
    hammer of thor asli

    ReplyDelete
  31. By reading this article many benefits that we can learn. thank you for sharing your insights to us all . alat bantu sex

    ReplyDelete
  32. http://obat.agenpembesarklg.com/2017/01/10/obat-kuat-thors-hammer-penis-besar-panjang-tahan-lama-0818733944/

    ReplyDelete
  33. http://obat.agenpembesarklg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  34. Sono molto felice di leggere questo. Questo è il tipo di manuale che deve essere data e non la disinformazione casuale che è agli altri blog. Apprezzare la vostra condivisione questo migliore distacco. rumah minimalis

    ReplyDelete
  35. This is a very good article material and it is very useful for us all. thank you . cara menggugurkan kandungan

    ReplyDelete
  36. So much we find the benefits of reading this article. hammer of thor

    ReplyDelete
  37. Bergabung Dan Tunjukkan Cara Bermain Pokermu.
    Bersama GadisPoker Dan Menangkan Hadiah jutaan Rupiah.
    Dan Jangan Lupa Juga kami Ada Promo Buat Anda.
    https://goo.gl/iXP5pY
    Untuk Info Lebih lanjut Silakan hubungi CS (custumer Service).
    -Live chat ( gadispoker )
    -Whatsapp : +855966624192
    -BBM : D87DB681
    agen judi poker online terpercaya di indonesia

    bandar judi poker online yang paling aman

    taruhan judi poker online terpercaya

    ReplyDelete